Compared to prior years the resolution of the 2006-2007 California state budget was a relatively benign affair. True it was still late as the constitutional deadline was June 15th. But like the line from the first Pirates of the Caribbean movie this constitutional provision has always been treated more like a "guideline" not a firm rule. (This alone tells us a lot about the fidelity to constitutional principles held by our ruling elites).
The budget was passed happily before the beginning of the fiscal year which started on Saturday. That has not happened since the year 2000. And there is more good news. A massive influx of new revenue is making it easy for Governor Schwarzenegger to adhere to his no-new-tax pledge while at the same time expanding state government to a level that more or less placates the tax-and-spend crowd.
How much new revenue? About $7.5 billion more than expected. Indeed all told revenues are up a staggering 23% over a 3 year period. While state politicians are all smiling about this revenue not everybody is smiling about how it is being spent.
First let’s give credit to the Governor for not raising taxes. Other Republican governors have raised taxes without having a legislature dominated by the opposition party. This governor understands thatraising taxes would inflict a fatal wound to California’s economic recovery.
Second while it is true that the national economic recovery has played a large role in the flood of tax receipts to California’s coffers the Governor can take substantial credit for setting the tone — in word and deed — that California is not as hostile to business as its reputation would warrant. Workers comp reform and job creation are two weapons Arnold will aim squarely at Phil Angelides this fall.
Now the bad news. Despite buckets of new cash California is still spending more money than it is taking in. It is a well-worn budget clichí© that if you find yourself in a hole the first thing you do is stop digging. Well California continues to dig away and that probably explains why in the budget vote a large number of Republicans said No.
Budget contrarian and fiscal expert Sen. Tom McClintock spells out the numbers in stark detail: Income: $94.4b; Spending: 101.3b; Deficit: $6.9b.
McClintock also makes a valid point with respect to the vaunted "paying down the debt" argument. Yes the budget does repay some debt but much of that which is characterized as "debt" reduction is merely transferring funds to prior obligations including transportation and education.
The sad truth for taxpayers is that it was truly a "get out of town" budget. Instead of addressing the structural deficiencies in the current budget process our political leaders have put it off yet again. And they did so for political reasons.
The Governor signed off on the massive spending increase to better position himself for his political battle against Angelides in the fall. He can rightfully claim that he has reached out to Democrats in the crafting of this budget which gave a huge infusion of cash to the prodigious education bureaucracy — a major constituency of the political left. The Republicans can claim that they have not raised taxes. The photo of the budget-signing ceremony was dominated by big smiles.
Yet California is still on the precipice. With all the new revenue we had a rare opportunity to step back from the cliff but our elected leaders demurred. We can only pray that our national economy doesn’t backslide because if it does there will be the same recriminations and finger-pointing that transpired when Gray Davis was unceremoniously kicked out of office.
Yes there are a few good things about this budget. Unfortunately it still fails to meet the ultimate acid test: It calls for spending in excess of revenues.
Jon Coupal is president of the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association — California’s largest taxpayer organization — which is dedicated to the protection of Proposition 13 and promoting taxpayers’ rights.
To print or download a PDF version of this commentary click here.
Permission to reproduce this commentary in any format is hereby granted.